Before you pack up your wd and return it, lets talk about. My external hard drive does not run automatically when plugged into my usb port on my computer. Western digital or seagate goflex 1tb external hdd. The backup plus portable 4tb drive came preformatted in ntfs. We prefer the colourful designs of western digitals my passport. Seagates drives are improving while western digitals. Wd vs toshiba vs hgst vs seagate which hard drives are. Well, from a purely anecdotal standpoint, i like western digital over seagate. Western digital black vs wd re enterprise vs seagate 2tb hdds. Neither requires external power sources, but your usb hub might need to be. Also, good luck getting amazon to rma a shucked drive. Halo pal, both disks are windows 10 compatible and will work on usb 2. Its in the top 3 bestselling external hard drives and has dozens of popular alternatives in the same price.
This means that for a small nas with an avoton and 4 notebook disks or ssds i would make a diy tiny case, with the disks at the bottom and the mobo above, and enforce airflow with a fan. Nov 10, 2018 hey volks, i need a new pc for prepar3dv4 and im not quite sure whats the best option. Feb 01, 2012 about two years ago i replaced all of my hard drives with hitachi 7k3000 2tb hard drives. Western digital nas red for personal storage solutions.
Im currently using wd red 3tbs in my array, and theyve been great. We dont know any external hard drives that are newer on the market. Jun 20, 2016 my own experiment worked well, but a huge passive heatsink like the nofan cr95c conflicts with my air path design. Seagates drives are becoming more reliable, as western digital drives seem to be getting worse, according to data from cloud storage company blackblaze. The root folder also had setup files that opened up the default browser for registering. Wd 2tb network nas hdd sata 6gbs 64mbcache nas drive for up to 5bay wdbmma0020hncnrsn. Supposedly the 2tb drives from seagate are less platters and higher density yielding better performance. Backblaze, an online backup provider, has published its hard drive reliability statistics for q2 2016, which reveal the reliability of different hard drive brands and models.
I have applied a hot fix for this problem and it was stated that problems are detected but after applying the hot fix the problem still exits. When push comes to shove, i always go with the more conservative balance. Scripts to report smart, zpool and ups status, hddcpu t. I realise that this question is about hard drive reliability, which is the most important consideration to me when buying an external drive. The reason that i have five is because they are solid drives at an outstanding price. See what being one of the top hard drive makers in the world brings to your. Western digital my passport portable hard drive, 4tb. Today we take a look at four of the latest 3tb drives to hit the market, from hitachi, seagate, and western digital. Then, you can restart computer to see whether the wd hard drive is recognized by windows 10.
Western digital provides data storage solutions, including systems, hdd, flash ssd, memory and personal data solutions to help customers capture and preserve their most valued data. Groot aantal 3tbdrives van seagate en wd vertonen gebreken. If it is, right click wd hard drive, choose properties and click update driver under driver tab or click on uninstall. Never answer quora questions when youre under the influence of s. Store files securely with this 4tb western digital my book hard drive. How to solve my wd hard drive not recognized in windows 10. Western digital and seagate both offer a variety of pocket external hard drives with differences in capacity and connectivity. And they all work interchangeably with windows and mac out of the box reformatting may be required for use with time machine.
I think theres a misconception that because the 3tb variants fail i. When it comes to storage, western digital and seagate are perhaps the two most recognisable brands in the market. The two big leaders in this field are wd and seagate with their respective wd red range and seagate nas drives. I used to have a set of logitech z5500s and my current setup totally destroys them. I used to be quite keen on the offerings of both verbatim and seagate.
Looking for some decent pc speakers that wont break the bank so i would like to. Im having trouble choosing between the wd black, and the seagate barracuda. Receive an email notification when this product becomes available. Adding smaller files to the mix causes speed to plummet further, frequently grinding to a dead halt yes zero kbs. With such a big emphasis on nas being the answer to all your. I use several hard drive diagnostics programs to certify the hard drives before i use them and to check for problems each week. Ive had my 2tb seagate barracuda for roughly 45 years, and ive yet to see it fail though i anticipate it to do so soon. Wd my book is a very popular and one of the more expensive options. Anybody have reservations about these in a areca raid setup vs. Seagate archive v2 8tb, seagate ironwolf nas 8tb or. I compare the performance of western digital black and western digital re enterprise with a seagate 2tb. I decided it was time to upgrade my harddrive today.
Western digital 3tb my book desktop external hard drive. See more ideas about wall mounted tv, swivel tv wall mount and laptop computers. Which is the most reliable 2 tb external hard disk seagate. A side benefit, when youre getting them shipped, is the added protection the retail packaging and physical construction provides.
Comparing revenue and key metrics for the two portable. By clicking the notify me when available button below, i consent to the use of the information provided below by. I primarily listen to music, secondary focus would be movies and games. Wd my book live 3tb personal cloud storage nas share. On the solid state front, both companies offer speedy drives designed to access and write your data as fast as possible. Sep 06, 2019 click disk drives and check if there is a yellow exclamation mark with wd hard drive disk device. External tb hd arrays promise pegasus2 r6, areca arc8050t2. My desk is also rather small and my monitor may interfere with projection see photo.
Seagate expansion portable was released this year in july. Unboxing western digital my book essential 3tb external. Overall, these are some of the most reliable drives over time that. Seagate ownsand why ill never buy another wd drive again general hardware. Which is better wd passport ultra 2tb or seagate backup. Western digital has been selling these external storage devices with the highest storage capacity drives in their class for some time now the 3.
Western digital hard drives and other quality brands offer several capacities, speeds, and. Apr 26, 2014 those features just arent needed in that home nas sitting on your bookshelf. What good is a backup drive if your backup drive fails. Holiday 2012 small form factor buyers guide anandtech. Western digital wd3000fyyz western digital re wd3000fyyz 3tb 7.
Id prefer to have a sub, but if bookshelf speakers can provide a solid range im all for it. Ironwolf 8tb have different screw holes, probably will fit in my case but just a heads. Western digital my book 8tb and my passport 4tb external. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd. Dec 05, 2012 western digital red drives also carry a 3year warranty, compared to the 2year warranty of western digital s green drives and many of seagate s higher capacity storage drives. Have not had a single problem with the hitachi drives. Although i now have 5 external drives, only one of them is large enough to back up the entire contents of my macbook. Read our complete guide on what external hard drive to connect to your machine. The firmware update to fix them came too late andor didnt work at all at least on my case. The wd 6tb my book desktop contains a wd60ezrz drive a western digital blue, 3. The 8tb version of the western digital my book is a deep well of affordable storage.
Combining onpoint performance and strong encryption, seagates backup. Seagate ownsand why ill never buy another wd drive again. Because im still dizzy from the anesthesia from last weeks surgery. Great drive for the price, especially when you catch it on sale. Build fanless bookshelf nas page 2 ixsystems community. Wd vs seagate which one should you choose featuring eddie. Continuing with the personal cloud theme, this unit from seagate takes its lead from my cloud, while offering far larger capacities, along with dual bays for two hard drives.
Wd elements is a very popular option in the middle of the external hard drives price range. Selecting a backup plus hard drive that matches your preferred interface is easy. It looks that i need to buy a new 2tb external hdd because my new only 3 months seagate 2tb external hdd have dieafter 3 months and i have use it only for backupsand this. I put a western digital 320gb in my macbook a few months back and since that point ive had a problem. Ironwolf 8tb have a high idle noise, seagate say you can fix this updating the firmware, but how knows. Full disclosure my current array is red but my backup is seagate nas drives the generation before they rebranded everything. In open air, spin and seek noise seems to be better than a nowneighbouring seagate drive, appearing to be very similar to some of my older wd green drives which i think these newer blue drives have largely.
The 1tb seagate barracuda 2016 stdm010 has an impressive performance profile. Its 5 gbps data transfer rate enables fast copying of files, and its automatic backup software can be set to fit any schedule. Seagate 14tb ironwolf pro 7200rpm sata iii 256mb cache 3. Western digital wins out when it comes to larger capacities, offering its my book duo amazon with 20tb of storage in either a raid 0 or raid 1 configuration, along with plenty of. Most importantly, it costs significantly less, just around 15 cents per gigabyte compared to some 25 cents of the seagate. Talking specifically about the size, the 4tb and 6tb hard drives were found to be most vulnerable, with 2. This item bovke protective case for seagate expansion desktop,western digital wd my bookelements desktop external hard drive usb 3.
When comparing seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd my passport, the slant community recommends wd my passport for most people. The small file 4k performance profile is less impressive but still adequate with average readwrites coming in at 0. Searching the internet for seagate disconnect mac returns lots of results that predate mavericks and also includes several results from windows users, which leads me to think this is a seagate problem. Choosing between wd and seagate what is the difference, which is best. This western digital my book hard drive offers builtin 256bit hardware encryption and optional password protection for peace of mind. An excellent mobile storage device for data files, movies, music, and pictures is a portable hard drive. Id definitely be up for other options if theyre out there.
I use a laptop with an i7 and 16gb of ram with a 4tb western digital red desk top hd in an external hd case with a usb 3. Everything worked perfectly, straight from go, the 3 tb of data i had on my former seagate goflex manually connected to a sata port on my p. Wd my book essentials 3tb posted in external hardware. The wd red sa500 ssd is western digital s formidable contender to seagate s ironwolf 110. Compare seagate 4tb backup plus portable hard drive vs wd 4tb my book desktop usb 3. With sequential readwrites averaging 173 and 159 mbps respectively, the barracuda can make short work of even moderately large backups. Hgst drives continue to impress as far as overall afr rates and this isnt the first year thats been true. I had mostly seagate hard drives prior to the swap out. The new nascentric solidstate drive proved to be faster than its rival in my testing. Jun, 2012 most of the time i use 2 bookshelf speakers and a powered subwoofer for the added impact arcade experience and at night i always use my sennheiser hd 595s for the immersive ultra loud late night gaming experience. Dec 20, 2018 i already had 4 bookshelf speakers and the sound card so it wasnt a huge expense to go the route that i did. I unbox a new western digital my book essential 3tb external hard drive. New pc for p3dv4, but which gpu monitors multimonitors. Bug head is a free program and has a learning curve.
My maximum is 1100 and ive already done some research and came to a system, but i wanna know your opinion my current idea is. Seagate backup plus hub 4tb external hard drive desktop hdd usb 3. Using the street price as of april 2010, we also calculated a costpergb for each of the ten hdds. The western digital wd black 4 tb wd4003fzex also has 64 mib of cache and uses a sata600 interface, but spins at 7,200 rpm. Oct 25, 20 the buggy western digital software discussed in most of this thread is an entirely different problem. It is not recognized in my computer and it does not show up in device manager. Western digital has several new products coming to market. What is needed is a wd caviar green that has tler, and western digital delivers that in their new red drives. Consumer drives shown to be more reliable than enterprise. I have never had a good wedtern digital hard drive. Seagate backup plus hub is a very popular option on the higher end of the price range. Western digital blue hdd 2tb vs seagate barracuda 2tb. Western digital external hard drive not recognized by windows.
The western digital 3tb drives have also failed more, with their rate rising from 4% to 7%. Populating your nas with drives could be as simple as dropping in the cheapest drives that meet your capacity needs, but thats a path. They rival each other in nearly every segment of the storage market and try to outdo each other with innovations in ease of use and power efficiency. Im going to get a ssd intel cherryville 120gb for the os and fast games crysis etc, but need a 2nd drive for. Seagate backup plus portable 4tb external hard drive hdd red usb 3. Seagate expansion 1tb portable external hard drive vs wd.
1397 538 972 715 647 564 1128 1060 468 1436 1506 1042 349 1104 1314 1363 596 1165 772 383 96 1504 1392 732 655 1186 35 200 635 513 419 1047